top of page

5 Critical Mistakes to Avoid with Underperforming Employees: Insights for CEOs, HR, and C-Level Executives

Updated: May 3

In every workplace, there are instances where employees may not meet the expected standards of performance.

This underperformance, can manifest in various forms, including missed deadlines, decreased productivity, and subpar quality of work.

While underperformance is a common challenge faced by organizations of all sizes and industries, its impact on organizational success cannot be overstated.

Over the upcoming weeks, we'll explore five mistakes to avoid and provide insights on how to effectively manage underperforming employees.

Here's a sneak peek into the five mistakes we'll explore and provide insights on how to manage underperforming employees effectively:

  • Lack of Clear Expectations

  • Neglecting Regular Feedback

  • Overlooking Training and Development Opportunities

  • Failing to Address Root Causes

  • Ignoring Opportunities for Growth or Transition

Stay tuned for in-depth insights on each of these critical mistakes and how to avoid them for better performance management in your organization.

Why Underperformance

An employee's performance may fall below the established standards or expectations for their role for a multitude of reasons, ranging from skill gaps and inadequate training to personal issues or disengagement.

Regardless of the cause, underperformance can have far-reaching consequences for both the individual employee and the organization as a whole.

Addressing Underperformance

Taking action against underperformance is not just a matter of addressing individual shortcomings; but of seeing the big picture in order to maintain organizational effectiveness and competitiveness.

There are several ways of addressing underperformance

  • Enhance Productivity and Efficiency:

The inability to meet deadlines or deliver quality work not only impacts the employee’s output but also creates bottlenecks and delays for other team members.

To ensure that workflow remains smooth and tasks are completed in a timely manner you can try the following:

  • Provide clear expectations and feedback

  • Offer training and/ or coaching to change habits and improve mindset

  • Reinforce with recognition for any positive change

  • Protect Team Morale and Engagement:

Be aware of any possible breed of resentment and frustration among other team members who may feel burdened by having to compensate for their colleagues' shortcomings, leading to a decline in morale and engagement, ultimately affecting the overall cohesiveness and effectiveness of the team.

- Address underperformance as soon as possible without delays. This demonstrates a commitment to fairness and accountability, which can help maintain a positive work environment and keep employees motivated.

  • Preserve Organizational Reputation:

In today's interconnected world, news of organizational inefficiencies or failures to address underperformance can spread quickly, damaging the company's reputation and credibility.

Clients, customers, and stakeholders expecting reliability and professionalism from leaders may put extra pressure to solve underperformance. Taking any short-cuts will serve you and your team poorly.

Take instead the time to address the cause of underperformance and act accordingly. You may download our free e-book with the 7 top causes of underperformance and how to solve them here.

  • Maximize Employee Potential:

Every employee possesses unique skills, talents, and potential contributions to the organization. However, underperformance can obscure or inhibit these capabilities, preventing employees from realizing their full potential.

Coaching empowers employees by recognizing and nurturing their unique skills and talents. Through personalized guidance, feedback, and support, coaching helps individuals overcome challenges and limitations, unlocking their full potential.

This tailored approach fosters growth, boosts confidence, and maximizes contributions to the organization's success. Let us share how coaching can help you unlock full potential in every employee.

You may get some insights from these real-life cases of people facing challenges, overcoming them with help from a High Performance Coach through simple exercises.

Case Study 1: CEO's Struggle with Time Management

Daniel, the CEO of a growing tech company, found himself overwhelmed with managing multiple responsibilities and meetings, often feeling like he wasn't making progress on strategic initiatives.

With guidance from a High Performance Coach, Daniel implemented a time-blocking technique, he worked in ”Pomodoro” slots, he defined daily routines in line with high-performance, he included mindfulness & breathing practices into his daily routines, amongst other easy to use tools.

He scheduled specific time slots for strategic planning, team meetings, and personal reflection, allowing him to focus on high-priority tasks and delegate effectively.

By adopting the Pomodoro technique, Daniel regained control of his schedule and improved his productivity, ultimately driving the company's growth forward.

CEOs can implement high-performance tools of easy use to increase time for strategic planning, team meetings, and personal tasks.

By focusing on the 20% that has the 80% of impact on the outcome important decisions and activities can be prioritized, reducing distractions, and maximizing productivity.

Case Study 2: HR Professional's Struggle with Employee Engagement

Sara, an HR manager at a medium-sized manufacturing company, noticed a decline in employee engagement and morale within her organization. Concerned about the impact on productivity and retention, Sara sought guidance from a High Performance Coach.

Together, they implemented regular feedback sessions and team-building exercises to foster open communication and strengthen relationships among employees.

Additionally, Sara introduced targeted employee training like workshops within Growth Mindset, Collaboration and Productivity to empower employees and enhance their skills, leading to increased motivation and job satisfaction across the organization.

HR professionals can improve employee engagement by partnering with high-performance coaches who can synergies their aims to increase team-building & collaboration leading to higher levels of engagement and employee satisfaction.

By creating a supportive and development-focused culture, HR professionals can boost morale, productivity, and retention within the organization.

To summarize this short, addressing underperformance in the workplace is not just a matter of correcting individual behavior; it is essential to look at the bigger picture for maintaining organizational effectiveness, preserving morale, and safeguarding reputation.

Understanding the importance of addressing underperformance and taking proactive steps to address it, organizations can create a culture of accountability, continuous improvement, and success.

If these challenges resonate with you, or if you’re facing other challenges Brighter Leaders is here to guide you.

340 views0 comments


bottom of page